Around the world, rather than understanding locally prevailing, hybrid systems of water rights, identities and governance forms, objectivist water science-policy-intervention schemes tend to enhance universalist, civilizing water expert notions. ‘Living’ water rules, rights and organizational forms are commonly dismissed or strategically aligned with dominant water culture. Modernist paternalistic or market-based policies to ‘recognize’ local water cultures harbour subtle politics of codification, confinement and disciplining.

Thereby, overlapping ‘governmentalities’ seek to produce ‘hydrosocial order’ – connecting local water practices and worldviews to supralocal schemes of belonging. This lecture discusses how efforts to reorganize hydrosocial territories and order ‘unruly’ water cultures engender policy models that depoliticize their deeply political choices. How they trigger cultural misrecognition, distributive injustice, political exclusion and often unsustainability. But this is not a one-way, dichotomist or deterministic affair. Hydro-territorial politics find expression in encounters of diverse actors with divergent spatial and political-geographical interests. Their territory-building projections and strategies compete, superimpose and align to strengthen specific water-control claims. Thereby, actors continuously recompose the territory’s hydraulic grid, cultural reference frames, and political-economic relationships, generating ‘territorial pluralism’. We discuss how efforts to establish, demystify or transform frames of water order are at the heart of water struggles. Thereby, hydrosocial territorialization is mediated by complex counter-forces and alternative water truths.

Instructor: Prof. Rutgerd Boelens

Rutgerd Boelens is Professor of ‘Water Governance and Social Justice’ at Wageningen University, The Netherlands, and Professor ‘Political Ecology of Water in Latin America’ with CEDLA, University of Amsterdam. He also is Visiting Professor at the Catholic University of Peru and the Central University of Ecuador. Coordination: the Water Law and Indigenous Rights alliance WALIR, the Justicia Hídrica/Water Justice alliance (www.justiciahidrica.org), and currently, the international action-research alliances “Riverhood” and “River Commons” (www.movingrivers.org). His research focuses on political ecology, water rights, legal pluralism, water cultures and cultural politics, governmentality, hydrosocial territories, river defense, and social mobilization, mainly in Latin America and Europe.